Second Former Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Does Not Recommend Impeachment of New Justice

Thursday, October 12th, 2023 -- 2:00 PM

(AP) A second former Wisconsin Supreme Court justice asked to investigate taking the unprecedented step of impeaching a liberal justice came out Wednesday against it.

Former Justice Jon Wilcox told The Associated Press that there was nothing to justify impeaching Justice Janet Protasiewicz, as some Republican lawmakers have floated because of comments she made during the campaign about redistricting and donations she accepted from the Wisconsin Democratic Party.

"I do not favor impeachment," Wilcox told AP in a telephone interview. Wilcox, along with former justices David Prosser and Patience Roggensack, were tapped by Republican Assembly Speaker Robin Vos to look into possible impeachment.

Prosser on Friday emailed Vos telling him that he was also against impeachment. Roggensack has not returned numerous messages seeking comment, including Wednesday. Vos floated impeaching Protasiewicz if she did not recuse from a redistricting lawsuit seeking to toss GOP-drawn legislative district boundary maps.

On Friday, she declined to recuse herself, and the court voted 4-3 along partisan lines to hear the redistricting challenge. Vos asked three former justices to review the possibility of impeachment, but he refused to name them.

Prosser told the AP that he was on the panel, but other justices either said they weren't on it or did not comment. In a court filing, Vos identified the other two as Roggensack and Wilcox. All three of those picked by Vos are conservatives.

Roggensack served 20 years on the court and her retirement this year created the vacancy that Protasiewicz filled with her election win in April. Wilcox was on the court from 1992 to 2007 and Prosser served from 1998 to 2016.

Prosser, a former Republican Assembly speaker, sent Vos on email on Friday advising against moving forward with impeachment. That was after a state judiciary disciplinary panel rejected several complaints lodged against Protasiewicz that alleged she violated the judicial code of ethics with comments she made during the campaign.

Prosser turned that email over to the liberal watchdog group American Oversight as part of an open records request. The group is also suing, arguing that the panel created by Vos is violating the state open meetings law.

Vos, in his court filing Wednesday, said he never asked the three retired justices to prepare a report or any other written work. The recommendations of the other two former justices have not been made public.

Wilcox said he had no plans to submit a written report. He said he, Prosser and Roggensack met one time and he told them then that he didn't think impeachment was warranted. Wilcox said he informed Vos of his opinion within the past two days.

Feel free to contact us with questions and/or comments.